Unless you’re an investor, you probably don’t have a lot of experience with multiple lenders (or real estate agents) to guide you in selecting the lender who can serve you best.
I recommend that you choose your Realtor first (and not an agent who is a non-Realtor) and get a referral of the best lender for your particular situation. Make sure it’s an agent who has done a lot of transactions, so he or she has had the opportunity to observe and evaluate multiple lenders.
Here is some of the advice I give to buyers. If they have already selected a lender — perhaps one they have used before, or a bank with which they have an existing relationship — I recommend that they talk to a mortgage broker so that they get the best possible deal.
How loan officers are compensated is a complicated business, and you need to be sure that the loan officer is putting your interest ahead of his own compensation.
You may think that interest rates are pretty uniform, but loan officers earn different commissions based on what interest rate and what loan product you select. This was one of the reasons for the housing crisis in 2008, because a loan officer could earn much more if he or she put you in a subprime loan even if you qualified for a conventional loan.
Many of those loan officers have changed professions by now. Nevertheless, it’s a good practice to have one loan officer evaluate the product and rate you have been offered by another loan officer.
I don’t have one loan officer I recommend. Instead, I have a stable of loan officers from which to choose based on your particular need or scenario. One is particularly good at improving credit scores to help a marginal borrower qualify for a mortgage. Some specialize in first-time home buyers and are certified to sell you a loan which, for example, can rebate 20% of your loan interest for the life of the loan. (This is the “MCC” program which has an income limitation and is limited to first-time buyers and veterans.)
A consistent piece of advice I give, besides talking to more than one loan officer, is to consider a mortgage broker as well as your banker, even though you feel “known” with him or her. First of all, your banker, unlike a mortgage broker, may not be available after business hours. Secondly, a bank can only sell its own products. What if you’re a teacher or police officer, and another lender has a program for you?
Or what if you want to buy a condo, and the condo you want is “non-warrantable” because the complex has over 50% renter occupancy or fails to meet some other approval criteria? Here is where I favor banks, because some banks have what are called “portfolio” loans — loans they don’t sell to Fannie Mae or Freddie Mac and that don’t have to be FHA or VA approved. Often these loans are done to satisfy a federal anti-redlining law from the 1970’s, the Community Reinvestment Act. I can point you toward a couple banks that are most active in satisfying that requirement to lend money in their depositors’ community.